Skip to Navigation
Bo-o-o-o-ring: A dull debate about who should replace Ted Kennedy in the Senate

Abdication: The Boston media gives away an important US Senate debate

If viewers and listeners were bored to death by Monday night's senatorial debate at the JFK Library, they have the usual suspects to blame - the media. Only this time, they are right. 

The entire expanse of Massachusetts television, radio and print media ceded control of the debate to the Edward Kennedy Institute for the United States Senate. Why, you ask? Because it was free - the Kennedy Institute paid for everything. And we all got what we paid for, nothing. The format was lame, the questions were lame, the production was lame and the result was tedious. And for the record, I opposed this lazy and cozy partnership.

Virtually every rule of "don't" was broken. Don't ask everyone the same question, don't ask yes/no questions, don't ask hypotheticals, and don't use a format that doesn't allow for interaction among the candidates.

Peter Meade is one of the most competent, knowledgeable and civically engaged people I know - but that does not make him a debate moderator.  Come to think of it, what he is, is senatorial material.

5 comments

Comments

FYI, our old friend John Carroll also weighed in on this topic with a commentary on WBUR.org:

http://www.wbur.org/news/wbur/people/jcarroll

Just out of curiosity, when's the last time anyone learned anything about a candidate or candidates during a debate for national or statewide office?

Kennedy v. Nixon?

Hard to believe we're going to be stuck with any one of them for the rest of their natural lives.

But we are.

You missed another rule for moderators that was broken: Meade has, in the past, contributed to the campaigns of two of the candidates. That's a big no-no.

Thanks Emily, Ralph,

For some reason I couldn't get into watching this TV show for too long. I kept coming back, staying for a bit then leaving. Even that Horse Trading section about How I as your Senator would get you Federal money was pretty lame. I did see Emily smile in her lone chair at WGBH.

Anyway based on style and media presence Martha won. I won't vote for her for a number of reasons, yet that is my observation.

The content of this field is required, but will be kept private and will not be shown publicly.